Fluoxetine vs St John's Wort

SSRI antidepressant versus herbal alternative for depression management

FluoxetinePharmaceutical

Brands: Prozac

Drug Class

SSRI

Effectiveness Rating

4/10

Safety Rating

4/10

Mechanism of Action

Selectively inhibits serotonin reuptake to increase serotonin levels in the brain

Common Uses

  • Depression
  • OCD
  • Panic disorder
View full profile →
St. John's WortNatural

Hypericum perforatum

Research Quality

strong

Effectiveness Rating

4/10

Safety Rating

3/10

Active Compounds

HypericinHyperforinFlavonoids

Modern Uses

  • Depression
  • Seasonal affective disorder
  • Mood disorders
View full profile →
Effectiveness Comparison

Fluoxetine more effective for moderate-severe depression. St Johns Wort comparable for mild-moderate depression in studies.

Safety Comparison

Both generally safe but with different side effect profiles. St Johns Wort has extensive drug interactions. Fluoxetine more predictable.

Cost Comparison

St Johns Wort much cheaper without prescription costs. Fluoxetine expensive without insurance.

Convenience Comparison

Fluoxetine requires prescription and monitoring. St Johns Wort available OTC. Both take 4-6 weeks for full effects.

Research & Evidence

Both have strong evidence. Fluoxetine extensively studied for depression. St Johns Wort proven for mild-moderate depression.

Expert Recommendation

Use fluoxetine for moderate to severe depression or when natural options are ineffective. Choose St Johns Wort only for mild-moderate depression with no drug interactions.

⚠️ Medical Disclaimer

This comparison is for informational purposes only. Always consult with a qualified healthcare provider before making decisions about medications or supplements.